Skip to content

IssuesHealth care

Health care

Offer a federal public health-insurance plan

Most working-age Americans who have insurance get it through an employer or buy a private plan, with subsidies for people who qualify on the individual market. A public option would add a government-run plan, paid for by premiums and by the same subsidies private plans can receive, that a person could choose instead of a private insurer. It is not a proposal to enroll everyone in Medicare. Private insurance would remain. What the plan pays hospitals and doctors — rates like Medicare, or rates negotiated like a private insurer — would shape both the premium and the effect on providers.

0 ballots on the record, including demonstration ballots. Open the count

Arguments in favor

  • Another plan would add a choice in markets that today have only one or two insurers.
  • A public plan would not pay shareholders. If it also pays providers less, premiums can be lower.
  • A person who loses a job would have a plan that does not depend on an employer.

Arguments in opposition

  • If the public plan pays hospitals and doctors less, those providers may raise prices for private plans or leave the public plan.
  • A plan backed by the Treasury can price below private insurers that cannot run a continuing loss, and crowd them out over time.
  • Running an insurance plan means payment errors, fraud control, and disputes become federal work.

These points summarize claims often made about this proposition. They are not a party platform, and CitizenVote does not endorse them. Both columns are given the same space.